11 Marketing + Design vs 887 Media for a local service site?

Hey everyone, I'm looking to overhaul our plumbing business website this year (finally updating the ancient site for 2026). I've narrowed my choices down to 11 Marketing + Design and 887 Media. Has anyone worked with either of these local agencies? I need something that actually brings in leads, not just a pretty digital brochure. Any pros/cons would be super helpful!