I ran my contractor quote through 4 AI estimators, here's the one that actually got it right
I had to price out a fence replacement for a client in Spokane. The guy wanted cedar, 240 linear feet, on a slope. I usually just eyeball it and eat the cost if I'm low. Last week I fed the same job specs into four different AI estimating tools just to see what came back. One said $8,200. Another said $14,600. The third gave me a materials list that included 3x the number of posts I'd ever use. The fourth one, which I'd never heard of before, asked for the slope angle in degrees, the frost depth, and whether the client wanted gates on both sides. That one came back at $11,850 and I ended up bidding $11,900. Client took it. I've already ordered materials and my margin is actually there. The other three were basically fancy calculators. The one that asked questions felt like it was learning the job, not just guessing. Has anyone else found that the AI tools which ask follow-up questions are way more reliable than the ones that just spit out a number?