A member in my club said my discussion questions were too broad, so now I write three specific ones for each chapter.

Aaron King · 2026-03-14T17:00:05.64333+00:00

After she pointed out that 'What did you think?' led to awkward silences, I started preparing questions like 'Why do you think the character lied in chapter 4?' and it completely changed our conversations.

leor837mo ago

Awkward silences from just "What did you think"?

7

linda_murphy7mo ago

Wait, your club actually had awkward silences?

3

miles5816mo ago

Remember that podcast about book clubs? The host said vague questions kill the vibe because no one wants to go first. That's exactly what happened here. @linda_murphy, I bet your club has those moments too, even if people don't admit it. Specific questions give everyone a clear place to start talking. It turns a big scary "what did you think" into a small puzzle anyone can solve. That shift from broad to specific is the whole game.

0