Loading…
11
A member in my old Seattle book club said my questions were too safe
We were talking about 'Beloved' back in 2018, and she told me my discussion prompts kept us on the surface. She said, 'You ask what happened, not how it felt.' I started framing questions around character emotions and tough choices, which changed our talks completely. Has anyone else gotten advice that shifted how you lead a discussion?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
gonzalez.grant4mo ago
Oh man, same thing happened to me. @jennyh55 nailed it with that pop quiz comparison, that stung but totally changed how I run things.
7
jennyh556mo ago
Honestly, I used to just ask about the facts of a story, like who did what and when. It felt tidy. Then someone pointed out I was treating a book club like a pop quiz. So I tried asking about why a character made a bad choice even when they knew better, or what a quiet moment in the book made people feel, even if it was uncomfortable. The talks got way more real after that.
6
gavink956mo ago
Got told my questions were once as bland as unbuttered toast. Started asking about the messy feelings instead of just the plot. Made me realize I was avoiding the awkward stuff that actually matters.
1