Can we talk about the $40 instant read thermometer debate that split my whole friend group?
I used to be the guy who said you don't need one, just poke the chicken with your finger and you'll learn. For years I cooked by feel in my tiny kitchen in Tucson, and honestly I burned a lot of thighs and had a few pink-in-the-middle disasters that I just shrugged off. Then about 8 months ago my buddy brought over a $40 instant read and we did a side by side on two pork loins, and mine was at 155 while his read 138 in the same spot. I bought one the next week and now I temp everything, even burgers, and my cooking has gotten way more consistent, but part of me misses the old way of just trusting my gut and learning from mistakes. My wife thinks the thermometer made me worse because I'm always second guessing and checking instead of just cooking. So here's the debate: is a cheap instant read a real upgrade or does it turn you into a nervous cook who can't trust himself? I want to hear from people who went back to no thermometer after using one, did you actually regret it or did your instincts come back fast?